• News
    • Latest news
    • News search
    • Health
    • Finance
    • Food
    • Career news
    • Content series
    • Try Devex Pro
  • Jobs
    • Job search
    • Post a job
    • Employer search
    • CV Writing
    • Upcoming career events
    • Try Career Account
  • Funding
    • Funding search
    • Funding news
  • Talent
    • Candidate search
    • Devex Talent Solutions
  • Events
    • Upcoming and past events
    • Partner on an event
  • Post a job
  • About
      • About us
      • Membership
      • Newsletters
      • Advertising partnerships
      • Devex Talent Solutions
      • Contact us
Join DevexSign in
Join DevexSign in

News

  • Latest news
  • News search
  • Health
  • Finance
  • Food
  • Career news
  • Content series
  • Try Devex Pro

Jobs

  • Job search
  • Post a job
  • Employer search
  • CV Writing
  • Upcoming career events
  • Try Career Account

Funding

  • Funding search
  • Funding news

Talent

  • Candidate search
  • Devex Talent Solutions

Events

  • Upcoming and past events
  • Partner on an event
Post a job

About

  • About us
  • Membership
  • Newsletters
  • Advertising partnerships
  • Devex Talent Solutions
  • Contact us
  • My Devex
  • Update my profile % complete
  • Account & privacy settings
  • My saved jobs
  • Manage newsletters
  • Support
  • Sign out
Latest newsNews searchHealthFinanceFoodCareer newsContent seriesTry Devex Pro
    • Opinion
    • The Rise of Chinese Aid

    Opinion: The promises and pitfalls of China's Belt and Road Initiative

    Four experts take a look at the initiative's economic implications.

    By Harinder S. Kohli, Johannes F. Linn, Rajat M. Nag, Leo M. Zucker // 23 October 2019
    Visitors walk past a wall with a map showing the species of peony in Belt and Road Initiative countries, at horticultural exhibition Beijing Expo 2019, in Beijing, China. Photo by: REUTERS / Stringer

    Since its launch in 2013, China’s massive Belt and Road Initiative has become a highly talked-about global development initiative. We have estimated that China has so far committed over $600 billion under BRI, which now encompasses some 133 countries.

    It is not surprising, therefore, that there are almost daily press stories about it, and numerous summits and meetings around the world have been convened to discuss it. Yet most of the current discourse, much of it critical of BRI, is limited to geopolitics; many of the initiative’s key economic aspects remain unexplored. And hardly any studies take into account the views of independent experts within BRI countries rather than what outsiders think.

    For Pro subscribers: Q&A: The 'intellectual father' of BRI on China's global development approach

    Devex Editor-in-Chief Raj Kumar sits down for a wide-ranging discussion with Justin Yifu Lin — one of the most influential thinkers in China on global development described as the "intellectual father" of the Belt and Road Initiative.

    To fill this glaring gap, we studied BRI as it affects eight countries in Central Asia and the South Caucasus region, where it is widely considered to be a potential economic gamechanger for this mainly landlocked region. Our work takes a deeper “inside-out” look at BRI from the perspective of these eight CASC countries.

    So, what did we find that is different than the headlines that we read daily?

    The answer is that while some of the criticism is indeed valid, the actual situation is much more nuanced: overall, most countries welcome this Chinese initiative, particularly large countries with good domestic institutional capacities such as Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan. The countries view this massive Chinese initiative as a unique opportunity to improve their competitiveness, attract needed foreign investment, diversify their economies, upgrade their physical infrastructure, enhance their trade flows, increase their fiscal revenues and — as a result of the foregoing — accelerate their economic development and improve their citizens’ standard of living.

    Yet embracing BRI is not without risks. Largely financed by loans from China, BRI investments may prove to be fiscally unsustainable for some recipient countries. This risk is heightened by often inadequate ex-ante assessment of BRI projects’ economic and financial viability and their social and environmental impacts. Moreover, without coordinated infrastructure investment planning or proper maintenance of new assets, some BRI projects could end up being wasteful or redundant. These pitfalls must be proactively addressed through policy and institutional reforms in the recipient countries.

    Such reforms have to be undertaken at the national and regional levels. At the national level, for example, proposed BRI projects must be integrated into national plans and priorities, and their economic and financial viability assessed ex-ante. Soft infrastructure developments — transit and trade facilitation, operations and maintenance, sector policy reform and institutional capacity building — need to be pursued in tandem with physical infrastructure developments. And greater transparency in procurement and more attention to the implementation of projects must be a guiding principle.

    At the regional level, economic cooperation must be deepened and accelerated in order for all countries to enjoy the benefits of greater connectivity with neighboring and world markets, mitigate negative spillover effects and conduct a joint dialogue with China.

    This brings us to the role of China. There are signs that Chinese policymakers are rethinking their approach to BRI. They are learning from experience gleaned during the first six years of this initiative, but also appear to be listening to the concerns expressed by the international community. Most of all, China seems increasingly concerned about recovering the billions of dollars it has lent to countries with fragile balance sheets.

    Whatever the motives, at the Second Belt and Road Forum held in Beijing this April, Chinese leaders announced major improvements in BRI, including: analysis of BRI countries’ debt sustainability in cooperation with IMF; mandatory, rigorous economic and financial analysis of all BRI projects; greening of the BRI; zero tolerance of corruption; and multilateralization of BRI through cooperation with 10 international organizations. If and when fully implemented, these reforms could potentially address most of the issues identified by us.

    BRI has the potential to transform the entire Eurasia landmass. To realize this historic initiative’s promise and avoid its potential pitfalls, BRI’s recipient countries must work with the global development community and China. But ultimately, these efforts to improve BRI will bear few fruits and will be heavily dependent on China’s ability to implement changes announced at the second BRI forum earlier this year.

    This will benefit not only all 133 BRI countries, but also preserve hundreds of billions of dollars of savings of over 1.35 billion Chinese people that are being invested overseas.

    • Trade & Policy
    • Banking & Finance
    • Central Asia
    • China
    Printing articles to share with others is a breach of our terms and conditions and copyright policy. Please use the sharing options on the left side of the article. Devex Pro members may share up to 10 articles per month using the Pro share tool ( ).
    The views in this opinion piece do not necessarily reflect Devex's editorial views.

    About the authors

    • Harinder S. Kohli

      Harinder S. Kohli

      Harinder S. Kohli is the founding director and chief executive of Emerging Markets Forum as well as founding director, president, and CEO of Centennial Group International, both based in Washington, D.C. He is the founding editor of the Global Journal of Emerging Markets Economies. He is also director of a number of other international companies, including LatinFinance.
    • Johannes F. Linn

      Johannes F. Linn

      Johannes Linn is a Ph.D. economist. He worked for 30 years at the World Bank. Since 2003, he has been affiliated with the Brookings Institution, the Emerging Markets Forum, and Results for Development. He engages in research and advisory assignments, including on the topic on scaling up development impact.
    • Rajat M. Nag

      Rajat M. Nag

      Rajat M. Nag is concurrently a distinguished fellow at India’s National Council of Applied Economic Research, and the Emerging Markets Forum. He also serves as chair of the Act East Council of the Indian Chamber of Commerce.
    • Leo M. Zucker

      Leo M. Zucker

      Leo M. Zucker has served as a project & research associate of Emerging Markets Forum and Centennial Group International since July 2017. In this role, he has contributed to numerous research projects on topics such as infrastructure development, fiscal management, climate change, health care access, and international organizations.

    Search for articles

    Related Stories

    China AidChina's big development projects are getting smaller

    China's big development projects are getting smaller

    China AidThe US aid freeze has left a funding gap. What if China steps in?

    The US aid freeze has left a funding gap. What if China steps in?

    The future of US AidSenate Democrats warn US is retreating and China is rising under Trump

    Senate Democrats warn US is retreating and China is rising under Trump

    Development FinanceCongressional hearing kicks off DFC reauthorization efforts

    Congressional hearing kicks off DFC reauthorization efforts

    Most Read

    • 1
      Opinion: How climate philanthropy can solve its innovation challenge
    • 2
      Closing the loop: Transforming waste into valuable resources
    • 3
      The legal case threatening to upend philanthropy's DEI efforts
    • 4
      FfD4 special edition: The key takeaways from four days in Sevilla
    • 5
      How is China's foreign aid changing?
    • News
    • Jobs
    • Funding
    • Talent
    • Events

    Devex is the media platform for the global development community.

    A social enterprise, we connect and inform over 1.3 million development, health, humanitarian, and sustainability professionals through news, business intelligence, and funding & career opportunities so you can do more good for more people. We invite you to join us.

    • About us
    • Membership
    • Newsletters
    • Advertising partnerships
    • Devex Talent Solutions
    • Post a job
    • Careers at Devex
    • Contact us
    © Copyright 2000 - 2025 Devex|User Agreement|Privacy Statement