On social media, the youth-training nonprofit looked like a model of a modern nonprofit: triple-digit growth, a blue-chip board, and prestigious foundation partnerships. But behind the scenes, the executive director told a different story: “Everything was duct tape and band-aids. We were growing on the outside but literally ripping at the seams on the inside.”
She is far from alone. Across 23 interviews with nonprofit leaders managing annual budgets from $500,000 to $20 million, I’ve noticed that growth (the very thing funders celebrate and demand) is breaking the sector’s most promising organizations.
The problem is an existential infrastructure crisis that remains largely invisible: When a CEO becomes the bottleneck for every decision, and when their personal “magic” remains the only engine for growth, the organization creates a dangerous dependency.







