• News
    • Latest news
    • News search
    • Health
    • Finance
    • Food
    • Career news
    • Content series
    • Try Devex Pro
  • Jobs
    • Job search
    • Post a job
    • Employer search
    • CV Writing
    • Upcoming career events
    • Try Career Account
  • Funding
    • Funding search
    • Funding news
  • Talent
    • Candidate search
    • Devex Talent Solutions
  • Events
    • Upcoming and past events
    • Partner on an event
  • Post a job
  • About
      • About us
      • Membership
      • Newsletters
      • Advertising partnerships
      • Devex Talent Solutions
      • Contact us
Join DevexSign in
Join DevexSign in

News

  • Latest news
  • News search
  • Health
  • Finance
  • Food
  • Career news
  • Content series
  • Try Devex Pro

Jobs

  • Job search
  • Post a job
  • Employer search
  • CV Writing
  • Upcoming career events
  • Try Career Account

Funding

  • Funding search
  • Funding news

Talent

  • Candidate search
  • Devex Talent Solutions

Events

  • Upcoming and past events
  • Partner on an event
Post a job

About

  • About us
  • Membership
  • Newsletters
  • Advertising partnerships
  • Devex Talent Solutions
  • Contact us
  • My Devex
  • Update my profile % complete
  • Account & privacy settings
  • My saved jobs
  • Manage newsletters
  • Support
  • Sign out
Latest newsNews searchHealthFinanceFoodCareer newsContent seriesTry Devex Pro
    • News
    • Technology

    Some tech for development experts are ready for Loon's last flight

    Loon, an accessible internet project by Alphabet, announced its closure Friday. Some in the development community were quick to say “I told you so,” noting that the effort has diverted attention and funding from proven technology and models.

    By Catherine Cheney // 25 January 2021
    A Loon balloon. Photo by: iLighter / CC BY

    Loon, a project by Google’s parent company Alphabet, announced Friday that it is shutting down its efforts to deliver the internet from high-flying balloons.

    Some in the development community were quick to say “I told you so,” noting that this effort by Alphabet’s moonshot factory has diverted attention and funding from proven technology and models.

    A range of experts working on affordable internet access and other tech for development efforts spoke out against Loon, posting on Twitter that it “sucked the air” out of affordable access discussions and distracted from “more realistic approaches” to connectivity.

    The Tweet https://twitter.com/stevesong/status/1352582873585512449 is not available.
    Via Twitter.

    Organizations working to connect the unconnected can strike a better balance between investing in existing approaches, and considering new technologies, according to John Garrity, an independent consultant to public and private sector organizations working on digital inclusion.

    “Moonshot projects in connectivity can be effective in highlighting the challenge before us and spurring organizations and governments into discussing and focusing on the issue of billions of people unable to benefit from internet connectivity,” Garrity said in an email to Devex.

    “The problem is when moonshots are viewed as the panacea, and draw resources and attention away from what we know can improve the situation today, which is conducive policy and regulations for market entry, competition and investment with proven technologies and flexible business models.”

    Loon is not Google’s only internet access initiative. When Google CEO Sundar Pichai spoke at the World Bank meetings last October, he did not mention the effort. Instead, he focused on Equiano, a subsea cable that will begin in Portugal and stretch to South Africa, with branching units along the way to extend connectivity to African countries.

    Still, Loon has drawn far more attention than CSquared, an effort to build fiber optic networks in Africa that started as an initiative within Google in 2011.

    “The problem is when moonshots are viewed as the panacea, and draw resources and attention away from what we know can improve the situation today.”

    — John Garrity, independent consultant on digital inclusion

    Alastair Westgarth, CEO at Loon, which was piloting its technology in Kenya, said his team could not find a way to get the costs low enough to build a sustainable business reaching people at the last mile.

    Astro Teller, captain of moonshots at X, Apple’s moonshot factory, pledged $10 million to support nonprofits and businesses focusing on connectivity, internet, entrepreneurship, and education in Kenya in the wake of Loon’s closure.

    A key lesson from Loon’s failure is that the business model is as important as the technology itself, said Henri Nyakarundi, an entrepreneur working on internet access, who noted the challenge of low revenue margins on the African continent.

    Tech companies working on connectivity in Africa “need to stop developing their own solutions and support or invest in local solutions that have a good understanding of the ecosystem,” he wrote in a LinkedIn post reacting to the Loon news.

    Loon is not the only example of Big Tech internet access effort that has failed, said Jim Cashel, author of “The Great Connecting: The Emergence of Global Broadband and how that Changes Everything.”

    “Other new technologies have also struggled,” he said, mentioning Aquila, Facebook’s solar-powered internet plane, which was grounded in 2018, as another example.

    Cashel said he is cautiously optimistic about Starlink, SpaceX’s effort to deliver broadband internet access from low Earth orbit satellites.

    “Unlike the other players, SpaceX hasn't really promoted the objective of linking remote populations in developing countries,” he said.

    Cashel said he hopes to see organizations approach Starlink about in-country beta testing, ideally beginning with schools and health clinics.

    But Loon may serve as a lesson on the opportunity cost of innovation. Laura Walker McDonald, senior director of insights and impact at the Digital Impact Alliance, said she sees it as a balancing act between experimentation with new innovations that may work and continued investment in proven technologies.

    “It’s important to weigh one against the other, acknowledging that there’s an opportunity cost to ‘moonshot’ technologies that don’t pan out,” she said in an email to Devex.

    McDonald explained the value of organizations taking a gradual scaling approach, using smaller pilots to test unproven ideas, gathering evidence, and scaling as they learn.  

    “I hope that the experience and lessons of the Loon project will be shared openly, which I have to say is not typical practice particularly in privately-developed tech,” she said.

    “It’s critical from an ethical and practice improvement perspective that we build evidence of effectiveness, outcomes, and eventually impact for all our interventions, and we have roundly failed to build a solid expectation and practice on that score across digital development and humanitarian technology.”

    More reading:

    ► Remote technologies find a role in COVID-19 response

    ► World Bank has role to play in inclusive digital connectivity, Google says

    ► What did 2020 reveal about 'meaningful digital access' for the last mile?

    • Innovation & ICT
    • Social/Inclusive Development
    • Private Sector
    • Loon
    • Alphabet
    • Kenya
    Printing articles to share with others is a breach of our terms and conditions and copyright policy. Please use the sharing options on the left side of the article. Devex Pro members may share up to 10 articles per month using the Pro share tool ( ).

    About the author

    • Catherine Cheney

      Catherine Cheneycatherinecheney

      Catherine Cheney is the Senior Editor for Special Coverage at Devex. She leads the editorial vision of Devex’s news events and editorial coverage of key moments on the global development calendar. Catherine joined Devex as a reporter, focusing on technology and innovation in making progress on the Sustainable Development Goals. Prior to joining Devex, Catherine earned her bachelor’s and master’s degrees from Yale University, and worked as a web producer for POLITICO, a reporter for World Politics Review, and special projects editor at NationSwell. She has reported domestically and internationally for outlets including The Atlantic and the Washington Post. Catherine also works for the Solutions Journalism Network, a non profit organization that supports journalists and news organizations to report on responses to problems.

    Search for articles

    Most Read

    • 1
      Lasting nutrition and food security needs new funding — and new systems
    • 2
      The power of diagnostics to improve mental health
    • 3
      The UN's changing of the guard
    • 4
      Opinion: Urgent action is needed to close the mobile gender gap
    • 5
      The top local employers in Europe
    • News
    • Jobs
    • Funding
    • Talent
    • Events

    Devex is the media platform for the global development community.

    A social enterprise, we connect and inform over 1.3 million development, health, humanitarian, and sustainability professionals through news, business intelligence, and funding & career opportunities so you can do more good for more people. We invite you to join us.

    • About us
    • Membership
    • Newsletters
    • Advertising partnerships
    • Devex Talent Solutions
    • Post a job
    • Careers at Devex
    • Contact us
    © Copyright 2000 - 2025 Devex|User Agreement|Privacy Statement