• News
    • Latest news
    • News search
    • Health
    • Finance
    • Food
    • Career news
    • Content series
    • Try Devex Pro
  • Jobs
    • Job search
    • Post a job
    • Employer search
    • CV Writing
    • Upcoming career events
    • Try Career Account
  • Funding
    • Funding search
    • Funding news
  • Talent
    • Candidate search
    • Devex Talent Solutions
  • Events
    • Upcoming and past events
    • Partner on an event
  • Post a job
  • About
      • About us
      • Membership
      • Newsletters
      • Advertising partnerships
      • Devex Talent Solutions
      • Contact us
Join DevexSign in
Join DevexSign in

News

  • Latest news
  • News search
  • Health
  • Finance
  • Food
  • Career news
  • Content series
  • Try Devex Pro

Jobs

  • Job search
  • Post a job
  • Employer search
  • CV Writing
  • Upcoming career events
  • Try Career Account

Funding

  • Funding search
  • Funding news

Talent

  • Candidate search
  • Devex Talent Solutions

Events

  • Upcoming and past events
  • Partner on an event
Post a job

About

  • About us
  • Membership
  • Newsletters
  • Advertising partnerships
  • Devex Talent Solutions
  • Contact us
  • My Devex
  • Update my profile % complete
  • Account & privacy settings
  • My saved jobs
  • Manage newsletters
  • Support
  • Sign out
Latest newsNews searchHealthFinanceFoodCareer newsContent seriesTry Devex Pro
    • News

    The Thorny Question of Neutrality

    By David Lepeska // 18 March 2009

    Can aid workers ever be truly impartial? The question arose this week after the International Rescue Committee

    that in 2005 it had considered cooperating with the International Criminal Court in its investigation of Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir.

    The problem of neutrality has proven nettlesome in recent years, particularly in places like

    , where Provincial Reconstruction Teams – all of which are sponsored by various foreign governments, including the U.S. – get involved in aid and development work. Such a blurring of the humanitarian space is clearly problematic.

    But in the case of Sudan the problem is even more complicated because the United Nations admitted to having no policy regarding the alignments and cooperation of NGOs and aid groups with which it does business, as long as they deliver relief.

    "What we encourage is all NGOs to respect humanitarian principles of neutrality, independence and impartiality," John Holmes said March 16 at U.N. headquarters in New York, acknowledging that there was some scrutiny. "That does not amount to us asking questions about whether they cooperate with the ICC because we don't think that's an appropriate question and that's for them to decide."

    Holmes is suggesting that the impartiality, even the morality, of an aid group is irrelevant. And what if the organization is supporting a dictator like al-Bashir, would that be a concern to the U.N.?

    "In theory it might be," said Holmes, "but I can't remember a case where this has come into question."

    He must have a poor memory. After the October 2005 earthquake in Kashmir, the U.N.

    relief money to two Islamist organizations, the Al Rashid Trust and Jamaat-ud-Dawa. The former is now on the U.N.'s sanctions list and the latter was recently shuttered by the Pakistan government as a front organization for Lashkar-e-Taiba, the Kashmir-based outfit that is accused of carrying out the recent Mumbai attacks.

    The U.N., which may have unwittingly funded terrorism, needs to be more careful about selecting partners. NGOs and aid groups, meanwhile, need to clarify their stance regarding cooperation with governments, multilaterals and other local and international parties.

    • Humanitarian Aid
    • Democracy, Human Rights & Governance
    Printing articles to share with others is a breach of our terms and conditions and copyright policy. Please use the sharing options on the left side of the article. Devex Pro members may share up to 10 articles per month using the Pro share tool ( ).

    About the author

    • David Lepeska

      David Lepeska

      David has served as U.N. correspondent for the newswire UPI and reported for several major newspapers, including the New York Daily News and Newsday. He was chief correspondent for the Kashmir Observer in Srinagar, India, and regularly contributes to the Economist, among other publications. Since 2007, David has reported for Devex News from Washington, New York, as well as South Asia.

    Search for articles

    Related Jobs

    • Privacy Lawyer (Hybrid)
      The Hague, Netherlands | Netherlands | Western Europe
    • Vice President
      Eastern Europe | Western Europe
    • Individual Consultant: Legal Specialist in Right-of-Way Acquisition
      El Salvador | Latin America and Caribbean
    • See more

    Most Read

    • 1
      Opinion: Mobile credit, savings, and insurance can drive financial health
    • 2
      Strengthening health systems by measuring what really matters
    • 3
      Opinion: India’s bold leadership in turning the tide for TB
    • 4
      Reigniting momentum for maternal, newborn, and child health
    • 5
      Opinion: Why vision is key to unlocking global development potential

    Trending

    Financing for Development Conference

    The Trump Effect

    Newsletters

    Related Stories

    HumanitarianTrump administration pushes controversial Gaza relief plan on UN

    Trump administration pushes controversial Gaza relief plan on UN

    HumanitarianGaza aid plan under fire as NGOs deny involvement

    Gaza aid plan under fire as NGOs deny involvement

    Devex DishDevex Dish: What WHA accomplished for nutrition — and the questions that remain

    Devex Dish: What WHA accomplished for nutrition — and the questions that remain

    The Trump EffectExclusive: World Vision braces for mass layoffs

    Exclusive: World Vision braces for mass layoffs

    • News
    • Jobs
    • Funding
    • Talent
    • Events

    Devex is the media platform for the global development community.

    A social enterprise, we connect and inform over 1.3 million development, health, humanitarian, and sustainability professionals through news, business intelligence, and funding & career opportunities so you can do more good for more people. We invite you to join us.

    • About us
    • Membership
    • Newsletters
    • Advertising partnerships
    • Devex Talent Solutions
    • Post a job
    • Careers at Devex
    • Contact us
    © Copyright 2000 - 2025 Devex|User Agreement|Privacy Statement