• News
    • Latest news
    • News search
    • Health
    • Finance
    • Food
    • Career news
    • Content series
    • Try Devex Pro
  • Jobs
    • Job search
    • Post a job
    • Employer search
    • CV Writing
    • Upcoming career events
    • Try Career Account
  • Funding
    • Funding search
    • Funding news
  • Talent
    • Candidate search
    • Devex Talent Solutions
  • Events
    • Upcoming and past events
    • Partner on an event
  • Post a job
  • About
      • About us
      • Membership
      • Newsletters
      • Advertising partnerships
      • Devex Talent Solutions
      • Contact us
Join DevexSign in
Join DevexSign in

News

  • Latest news
  • News search
  • Health
  • Finance
  • Food
  • Career news
  • Content series
  • Try Devex Pro

Jobs

  • Job search
  • Post a job
  • Employer search
  • CV Writing
  • Upcoming career events
  • Try Career Account

Funding

  • Funding search
  • Funding news

Talent

  • Candidate search
  • Devex Talent Solutions

Events

  • Upcoming and past events
  • Partner on an event
Post a job

About

  • About us
  • Membership
  • Newsletters
  • Advertising partnerships
  • Devex Talent Solutions
  • Contact us
  • My Devex
  • Update my profile % complete
  • Account & privacy settings
  • My saved jobs
  • Manage newsletters
  • Support
  • Sign out
Latest newsNews searchHealthFinanceFoodCareer newsContent seriesTry Devex Pro
    • News
    • UK aid

    UK government dodges questions about the future of ICAI

    The government failed to reassure parliamentarians concerned about the scrutiny of U.K. aid during a debate on the DFID-FCO merger Wednesday.

    By William Worley // 10 July 2020
    James Cleverly, joint minister of state for DFID and FCO. Photo by: Peter Nicholls / Reuters

    LONDON — The U.K. government repeatedly failed to offer reassurances about the future of the Independent Commission for Aid Impact on Wednesday, despite questions from parliamentarians concerned about the future scrutiny of development policy.

    James Cleverly, a minister with joint foreign affairs and development briefs, answered questions from politicians debating the forthcoming merger of the Department for International Development with the Foreign & Commonwealth Office.

    The government was urged on several occasions to retain ICAI, which is widely viewed by development experts as a critical aid spending watchdog, even attracting the attention of other donors looking to improve their development programs. But when addressing the question of scrutiny, Cleverly did not reference the extra-governmental body.

    For Pro subscribers: Watching the watchdog: What has ICAI done for UK aid?

    Little known to the public, the U.K.'s official aid watchdog has built a reputation as a vital tool in improving the country's aid. As it nears the end of its first decade, what has ICAI achieved?

    He said: “Scrutiny as a minister is a bit like a trip to the dentist. It is sometimes painful but it is absolutely necessary and it is for the greater good. And we welcome scrutiny and I have no doubt that our ODA [official development assistance] in the future will be scrutinized, scrutinized effectively. And we welcome that scrutiny, because we are proud of the work that we do.”

    Many experts are concerned, however, that there has been little detail about what that scrutiny will look like under the new Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office. The International Development Committee, a cross-party group of politicians which acts as another key strand of development scrutiny, is already under threat of closure.

    Public money “must be scrutinized by this House and made sure it is spent appropriately and correctly, and that’s why I am passionate in defending the ICAI commission,” said Tom Tugendhat, chair of the Foreign Affairs Committee, which monitors FCO and could be responsible for scrutinizing development policy going forward.

    Cleverly also did not answer questions about a consultation with NGOs and development experts on the DFID-FCO merger, which Labour Member of Parliament Mary Kelly Foy said Prime Minister Boris Johnson had “misled” Parliament about.

    He did however say the U.K.’s spending of 0.7% of gross national income on ODA would remain and that using at least half of that in fragile- and conflict-affected states would be an “enduring commitment.”

    Defending the timing of the merger in the middle of a pandemic, he said “I don’t envisage a point in time when there will be no major significant challenges around the world to give us breathing space and headroom to make changes.”

    The debate saw arguments from across political parties, with politicians often voicing concern about the merger and the potential consequences for U.K. development policy. Shadow International Development Secretary and Labour MP Preet Kaur Gill warned against returning to a past when “aid used to oil the wheels of trade deals.”

    “Scrutiny as a minister is a bit like a trip to the dentist.”

    — James Cleverly, Conservative MP

    Former Secretary of State for International Development and Conservative MP Andrew Mitchell — who created ICAI — described the merger as an “extraordinary mistake” and warned of a narrative that moved the U.K. away from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development-Development Assistance Committee rules that govern aid spending.

    But fellow Conservative MP Bob Seeley, who has long advocated for the merger, said “we do need to look again at ODA. We are permanently trying to revise the rules on ODA and we should not be ashamed to do so.”

    Tugendhat also voiced his support for the merger but highlighted some criteria that he said would be necessary for success, including maintaining the “culture” of DFID and not making the mistakes of the merger in Australia, which was blamed for a loss of development expertise.

    “We must remember … it's a merger of equals and not a takeover … [or] perhaps this is a DFID takeover” of FCO, he added.

    Mark Garnier MP, who serves as co-chair of the Conservative Friends of International Development, said he would advocate for cabinet representation. “One thing that may be a good idea would be to have a Chief Secretary of International Development in the same way they have a Chief Secretary of the Treasury,” he said. He also suggested that a permanent secretary — a top civil service official — for development would be “helpful,” although the government has already said there will be only one permanent secretary for the new FCDO.

    Garnier also stressed the need for clarity over the role of DFID on the U.K.’s arms export control, where the department sits alongside the Ministry of Defence, FCO and Department for International Trade, offering a humanitarian perspective on discussions.

    • Trade & Policy
    • Democracy, Human Rights & Governance
    • FCDO
    • DFID
    • United Kingdom
    Printing articles to share with others is a breach of our terms and conditions and copyright policy. Please use the sharing options on the left side of the article. Devex Pro members may share up to 10 articles per month using the Pro share tool ( ).

    About the author

    • William Worley

      William Worley@willrworley

      Will Worley is the Climate Correspondent for Devex, covering the intersection of development and climate change. He previously worked as UK Correspondent, reporting on the FCDO and British aid policy during a time of seismic reforms. Will’s extensive reporting on the UK aid cuts saw him shortlisted for ‘Specialist Journalist of the Year’ in 2021 by the British Journalism Awards. He can be reached at william.worley@devex.com.

    Search for articles

    Related Jobs

    • Director Advocacy and Strategic Partnerships
      Nairobi, Kenya | Kenya | Eastern Africa
    • Deputy Country Director – Programs Delivery
      Nairobi, Kenya | Kenya | Eastern Africa
    • Political Advisor on International Affairs
      Brussels, Belgium | Belgium | Western Europe
    • See more

    Most Read

    • 1
      Opinion: Mobile credit, savings, and insurance can drive financial health
    • 2
      How low-emissions livestock are transforming dairy farming in Africa
    • 3
      Opinion: India’s bold leadership in turning the tide for TB
    • 4
      Strengthening health systems by measuring what really matters
    • 5
      How AI-powered citizen science can be a catalyst for the SDGs

    Trending

    Financing for Development Conference

    The Trump Effect

    Newsletters

    Related Stories

    UK Aid5 years after UK aid merger, 60% of development adviser jobs are empty

    5 years after UK aid merger, 60% of development adviser jobs are empty

    UK Aid8 questions we still have about the future of UK aid

    8 questions we still have about the future of UK aid

    UK aidWho is Jenny Chapman, the new UK development minister?

    Who is Jenny Chapman, the new UK development minister?

    UK AidFormer UK development minister 'absolutely horrified' by foreign aid cut

    Former UK development minister 'absolutely horrified' by foreign aid cut

    • News
    • Jobs
    • Funding
    • Talent
    • Events

    Devex is the media platform for the global development community.

    A social enterprise, we connect and inform over 1.3 million development, health, humanitarian, and sustainability professionals through news, business intelligence, and funding & career opportunities so you can do more good for more people. We invite you to join us.

    • About us
    • Membership
    • Newsletters
    • Advertising partnerships
    • Devex Talent Solutions
    • Post a job
    • Careers at Devex
    • Contact us
    © Copyright 2000 - 2025 Devex|User Agreement|Privacy Statement